« Great Chicago Novels | Main | Weekend Multimedia »

Fundamentalism, here we come.

The Illinois state legislature has overturned Gov. Blagojevich's veto of "The Silent Reflection and Student Prayer Act", which mandates a moment of silence at the start of the school day in all of Illinois' public schools. Not surprisingly, lawmakers are quick to say this isn't about prayer in schools, when of course that's exactly what it's all about.

Here's the comment I left in the Tribune's discussion forum:

Okay, Springfield lawmakers, read this once again: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." This applies to state lawmakers as well.

I can't even begin to describe what terrible public policy this is. While lawmakers will certainly try to claim there are no religious motives behind this, the very name of the legislation - "The Silent Reflection and Student Prayer Act" - belies that claim. Making the moment of silence mandatory just opens the door for teachers who are religious to suggest, whether subtly or bluntly, that their students spend their quiet time in prayer - most likely of the Christian variety. "Come on," I can hear teachers saying. "You have to be quiet anyway, why not just pray to Jesus?"

This legislation is the most slippery of slopes, and I really don't like what awaits us at the bottom of that hill.

This legislation is the latest in a long line of reasons I'm grateful that my wife is homeschooling our six-year-old daughter, and keeping her as far as possible from the public school system.

October 12, 2007 in Current Affairs | Permalink

Comments

Pete- I couldn't agree with you more. As the rest of the world is racing towards fundamentalism, this country feels it must keep in pace.
As a child, I was an agnostic and felt it was presumptive of adults to assume I believed in a Christian god. After being thrown out of Sunday school for asking if god was a woman (if He gave birth to the Universe, whose uterus did He borrow?) I developed a skeptical view of churches. Today my view is more cynical as I witness churches around the country continuing to drum up money with the hate-based fundraising issues.
Prayer laws set dangerous precedents on the infringement of civil rights and establishment of "national religion." In a multi-cultural society, this is bound to become problematic. In our school, we sing the National Anthem, America the Beautiful, recite the Pledge of Allegiance (I give a lesson on what "indivisible" means- after saying it as a child ad nauseum and never having it deconstructed by my teachers) and then we recite the Peace Builders Pledge (which for me has more resonance). Since I go to different classes each day, depending on the class, I can barely get some to stand and pledge- let alone be quiet for the other morning announcements. Good luck getting them quiet in Illinois. Often when I hear people say "I will pray for you," I imagine they are really flipping me a verbal bird.

Posted by: Frank Jump at Oct 13, 2007 10:33:46 AM

I used to joke that I would be the only parent homeschooling my kids because there wasn't *enough* science being taught in school. Now I just muse cheerily on the fact that people of all political and religious stripe are yanking their kids out of public schools. I am pumped to watch the mess implode.

Posted by: Al at Oct 15, 2007 12:41:25 PM